Bulletin #1
Notes on Transcending Global Alienation
created 15jul2010
last revision 27sep2020
"The reform of consciousness consists only in making the world aware of its
own consciousness, in awakening it out of its dream about itself, in explaining
to it the meaning of its own actions.... The world has long since dreamed of
something of which it needs only to become conscious for it to possess it in
reality."
— Karl Marx
INTRODUCTION
In class society one expects "endless" war.
If so, why are we here?
Why do I feel as deja vu? I got here somehow, yet where do I go
from here? Could I be here for some other purpose than what immediately
presents itself? ? How can I make this more meaningful and
consequential than passively consuming
a series of speeches telling me how to vote, or a call to trod down
dreamless streets, a repeat of recycled failures? How do I create a
next and lasting step?
Stepping beyond…... misery, violence, and exploitation which appear — daily and everywhere —
polite and fuzzy, as well as terse and brutal — yet remain
invisible and fragmented in terms of what it really is: class war. What
is class society today and how does it manifest itself above us and as
us, as our own distorted reflection? How do we comply? How do we
commiserate? How do we perpetuate? How do we self-enslave? How is daily
life reproduced as the terrain of our own imprisonment? How do we
self-liberate?
We had better assess this current situation.
SITUATION: ALIENATION
We are each born into this world, and this world is not our making, vis-à-vis,
ourselves as real beings, born and raised in certain historical
conditions. We find ourselves in a world, and in political/economic
systems which are overwhelming in their scope, power, and historic
inertia. We all feel ourselves to be individuals, yet we all
participate in a kind of collective, social dance between consciousness
and unconsciousness. What is this "collective consciousness?" Where and
how is it created? How does it manifest itself? Was it always in
existence? If not, then how did it come to be?
It seems to us there
is, potentially at best, a kind of quasi-collective consciousness, a
sense of pseudo-community, that exists as a kind of ideal projection
which stands over and above our potentially-real
daily lives. But really, what exists now, is not a "collective
consciousness" or real community, but rather just its opposite — an
alienated projection of class interests, which means: hierarchical
power, antagonistic division, and mass codependency. What passes for
consciousness of community is really nothing but the
pseudo-collectivity of capitalist class power relations.
These power relations
define the world of accepted ideas, as well as, the modes of
communication, and the goals and means of a social system whose basic
relation is separation, not community. In other words, the
consciousness of the pseudo-solidarity of social life is disengaged
from the community of real human beings and given an autonomous power
over and above the disenfranchised and powerless mass of individuals.
The social power that
is alienated, extracted, and consecrated "outside" or "external to"
those who created it, is "separate power". Once consecrated and
institutionalized, it protects itself from the reappropriation of
disalienated creators via variant forms of social control:
mass-hypnosis, emotional manipulation, character-armor production,
commodity fetish, the commodity form, capital accumulation,
and State power. In other words, what passes for the consciousness of
our shared social identities becomes the ideology of a spectacle which
appears over and above us - to appear as, simultaneously, the totality
of society and a part of society which stands superior to the rest: the
world of separate power. The products and creativity that are daily
disengaged from all individuals, primarily through work and ideologies
of consumption, then return as an alien force which rules over us, and
which form the means and goals of daily life in capitalism. In the
broadest sense, this alienated power becomes our "economy," our
"government," our "world." A "second nature" appears to cover the
globe, to exist without question, and becomes the sun which always
shines over modern passivity. This spectacle gives a global voice to
the laudatory monologue of disguised power-relations, always assuming
its own glory — while spicing this spectacular stew with fragmented
views of emerging crisis, breakdown, violence, war, mass starvation,
disease, ecological decay, and global catastrophe. This is the woeful
map of our alienation, which has now become a global system.
In a very real sense,
this human world is "created by ourselves" — but created in conditions
that none of us have chosen, and that none of us have any clear way of
changing, and that none of us are being asked to change, and, in fact,
this system is a class system, which means that it is presided over by
people who suffer from the illusion that they benefit from this
state-of-affairs, simply because they squeeze out monstrous wealth and
power. By using their control of resources, their technologies of mass
communication and ideological projection, their seductive methods of
commodity fetishism, and, when necessary, their police, their armies,
their means of surveillance, their prisons, their skills of torture and
mind-control, and of course, their politicians, their bureaucrats -
they thus insure the security of their positions as top-dogs, as
king-rats, as chief-cannibals over a reified and alienated world. All
power to the ruling class! They have the power precisely because you
don't.
DEFINITION: CAPITALISM
The system of commodity and exchange-value production, of
capital accumulation and expansion is the basic mode of operation of
capitalist society. It is "how things work." And it appears to us, its
humble servants, as totally Natural, the "way things work" — primarily
because the system has produced a way of life, a culture, that has
become all-encompassing. "All we see are things and their prices."
Through the mode of commodity production, that is, wage and salaried
labor, there is a hidden secret, a sleight-of-hand, which when seen for
what it is, can be exposed as the source of wealth/poverty, class
antagonism, and the accumulation of CAPITAL.
Through this process
there is an accumulation of wealth in the hands of the owners of
capital, despite the fact that it is the workers who do most of the
work, who produce the commodities, who sell their life-energies in
exchange for the means of survival. And this process creates the
relation of ALIENATION, which is the name of a relationship by which we
disown control over our daily lives. Through the productive modes of
wage labor and capital accumulation a surplus of wealth is created that
then stands opposed to the workers that produce it — and its
accumulation as capital stands as an embodiment of wealth that the
workers are obliged to continue to work for, to sell themselves to, to
exchange their lives, skills, time, and energies. The means, uses,
products, and technologies are already automatically owned and
controlled via the ownership of capital. The workers, ourselves, become
commodities, and we sell ourselves for a price — for wages. The
accumulation of capital, as generated by the separation of the surplus
created by the workers, is placed in the hands of the owners — and
this "theft" is the normal working of the system. This accumulation of
capital cannot just stand pat, it is not a one way street, but rather a
cycle — the whole circuit of wage-labor --> commodity production --
exchange — capital accumulation -> wage-labor - commodity
production --> exchange ----> accumulation --> and round and
round, must successfully make it through each stage of the cycle, must
complete the circuit, or else there will be social breakdown, and
crisis. And the system is very vulnerable to such crisis. Further, each
accumulated capital, and the system of capitalism as a whole, must
expand and accumulate, must fight for dominance in the market and for
control of resources, trade, labor. There is an inherent need for
expansion in capitalism, and thus an inherent conflict between various
capitalist ownerships and between national organizations of capital (as
in national states). Competition will always evolve toward control and
monopoly. There are many potential points of conflict and breakdown in
this system — because there are inherent contradictions in its
functioning. But the point is that this system is a particular system,
it is a game with its own particular rules, and its seizure of control
of human society was a real historical process. Yes, commodity exchange
of various kinds, and at various levels, existed before capitalism. But
the evolution of capitalism and its form of surplus generation and
ownership meant that the development of commodity relations became the
DOMINATING organizing force of society, and this organizing force
inherently must expand and control more and more and more territory, it
must be able to render more "things," more resources, more people into
the commodity form. It cannot stop this process without going into
crisis — it must break through all limits, all resistance, it must
colonize human life intensively and extensively. This colonization
requires a quantification of human social reality — in which the
workings of "the market", of commodity exchange, of profit and
accumulation require a money-form to facilitate the whole process.
Again — what we find in our daily lives are "things and their prices".
That is the world we live in, this is the dominating force that builds
cities, creates technologies, stands behind imperialisms, creates the
growing contradiction between wealth and poverty, creates tensions that
can lead to war, renders everything it touches into a market relation,
and comes up against its own limits.
CONFINATION: THE STATE
The (Nation-)State maintains this state of affairs.
"National identity," nationalism in all its
forms, in all its corporate-statist, pseudo-socialist, and theocratic
varieties, is yet another mode of reification, another form of
alienation and ideology, that is, a form of false self-identification. Make
no mistake about it, these various statist forms are all competing
forms of alienated power, ruling over you, always subjugating, often in
your name. "National Identity" has the primary role in modern history
of providing an ideological identification as to facilitate an
organized rationalization for the accumulation of capital. As such, it
is inherently a means of class
exploitation, and an ideology by which the people of the world are
divided against themselves. Nationalism projects a false sense of
security and community. The modern state has the basic function of
insuring the maintenance and continuation of modern forms of social
control, i.e., class division and the smooth functioning of capitalism.
The State also provides the screen for the illusion of "democratic"
participation, as well as, the physical means of force and compliance,
in both its "democratic" and blatantly autocratic forms. It is also the
primary organizational tool for war and production for war — in the
service of capital expansion and conquest. It serves to sidetrack
potential working-class consciousness, international solidarity, and
self-organization on the part of the people of the world, and thus to
divert potential post-national class consciousness and organization
into the dead-ends of sectarian rivalries, trade conflict, and military
confrontation. As a means of separation, "national identity" is a tool
for counter-revolution, for localized enslavement, and for class
submission. Ironically, it is through the development of capitalist
expansionism on a global scale that the notion of "national state" is
becoming superseded by way of the ascendancy multi-national
corporations, and "globalization." We are in an historic period where
national statist ideologies are being undermined by the requirements of
globalized capital. The legalistic confines of national states are
being superseded through the globalistic, quasi-international alliances
that facilitate the extraction of surplus value on a global scale.
"Outsourcing" is just one the means of this global hyper-expansion --
which not only brings about the outsourcing of profitable accumulation,
but also renders working class contestation more and more impotent, as
areas of conflict can be pacified by way of the threat, and the
reality, of the removal of capital investment to elsewhere, and thus
the removal of the means of survival for the now-unemployed leftover
workers. But "national identity" still plays a manipulative role to
insure mass-psychological adherence to statist ideologies, that is, to
render the world's working classes obedient to nationally organized
forms of capital. Anyone who has any confusion about the meaning of
"national identity" in the face of the global manipulations of
corporate capital can just look at the deterioration of the
industrial base and physical infrastructure of American society to see
what "national identity" really amounts to. The powers-that-be have no
qualms about letting you "go under" if that means a plus in their
profit margin. You are expendable, because you really don't matter,
unless you are profitably exploitable. The system does not work — you
lose.
National identity is
not a cultural, ethnic, or tribal identity. The rise of the
nation-state, as the primary social tool to organize masses of people,
is a relatively recent development in human history. This modern
nationalist form arose with the ascendancy of capitalism. The national
state developed to facilitate and rationalize capitalism as a ongoing,
hegemonic social-economic force. As capital accumulates in competition
and often at odds with itself (as various competing centers of
accumulation), then the State plays the role of maintaining and
overseeing the whole process — so as to insure smooth functioning of
the local, regional, and global functions of exploitation, capital
accumulation, and commodity circulation. The State also serves to
"socialize" costs, that is, to find ways to make "society as a whole"
pay for programs and infrastructure necessities that, in fact, serve
the interests of the capitalist system. Thus these programs ultimately
serve the interests of a particular form of social-economic
exploitation, that is, serve the interests of a ruling class.
Nationalism is just one of the various ideologies that are developed,
projected, absorbed into, and manipulated within the minds of "its"
people — maintaining class
social relations — they become the false consciousness and pseudo-self
identification
which serve the interests of a ruling-class, and of people reproducing
themselves as a subservient class; they become the social-norm which is
taken as given, forming
part of the "natural backdrop" of social life. These ideas, which are
ultimately vulnerable to criticism, become instead, the "way things
are". Alternatives are eclipsed from view or not allowed to develop at
all, or when necessary, are excised from official history. The
processes of our socialization become our processes of domestication
and "our way of life". A social amnesia pervades daily life. A longing
or feeling that "something ain't
right", that something is missing, becomes a kind of "public secret".
Internalized coping mechanisms — cynicism, "acting out", anxiety,
helplessness, displaced aggression become behaviorally dominant - which
further advertises and validates our subjugation. Powerlessness
corrupts, absolutely.
PERMEATION: IDEOLOGY
Ideology is the method for accepting a topsy-turvy world.
The ideas of the
ruling classes permeate society, not only because those with power have
access to the means of ideological proliferation and indoctrination,
but also because these ideas are the ideas on which their own power
rests — they reflect certain belief systems, certain modes of
behavior, certain ways of seeing and being in the world. Ways of living
reproduce the power relations of exploitation. They become the ideological
framework that is barely perceived at all, precisely because it
is everywhere. The forms (and content) of ideological control
co-reflect a generalized indoctrination, passivity, and domestication.
These forms include: one-way mass-propaganda, manipulation and seduction of induced
commodity fetishism, pseudo-political debate, ersatz
life-style choices, spectacle-enthrallment, survivalist insecurity,
social isolation, dumbification, regressive infantilism, and
manipulated aggression. These are some of the psycho-ideological tools
employed by the specialists in power. The adherence to "national
identity" is just one of the means, and actually, a quite banal one at
that. It is used to keep you "in your place" by way of a birth-to-death
process of constant ideological reinforcement. You are, for example,
American, French, Chinese, etc. — that is, a "citizen" of an
abstract entity — given a quasi-geographical existence (presided over
by structures and forces that are barely understood at best, at least by
you). In a sense, you are a slave. Not technically of course, because
in the vast majority of cases, you are a "wage-slave", a human commodity,
to be hired (sold) as labor. As such, you become just another commodity
amongst all the others in a world drenched in commodities — that is,
you are a thing, an object — a living thing whose life energies are
taken from you, in a life-long requirement to service the needs of
capitalist and State. Your subjectivity, at best, exists and manifests
around the edges of your life, as your private world — where you hope
and believe your "real life" might be found. The real needs for
meaningful relationships, for lives of authenticity, of community, for "religious" transcendence,
for self-realization in a world where we can truly recognize ourselves
— all hide in our tiny worlds of constricted, personalized enclaves.
The potential adventures of self-discovery and self-development are
always being undermined and infringed upon by a world which surrounds
and permeates, a world constructed by the processes of alienated power.
In a sense we are victims of this system, but only as long as we accept
that role. We are both the victims and the sustainers of this system, and can get
beyond it only by comprehending and transcending our role.
Understanding the basic modes of the system's hidden operations can give insight into global
capitalism and its corresponding world crisis. The problem at hand is
to realize that, actually, we are not victims — we are the creators of
our world, but we create that world according to rules that are not of
our conscious making. We do inherit the results of history up to this
point, for better and worse. Capitalism has revolutionized the world,
no doubt about that! There are countless ways that we benefit from this
system, but these benefits have also become a dependency, we are
trapped in a situation that seems beyond control, beyond the possibility
of real transformation. But everything has its limits. The system is
full of contradictions that lead it to crisis, and those crises have
nasty way of a becoming deeper and more profound. And really, the
primary crisis is the colonization of daily life by capital, and the
rendering of us all into being servants of its quantitative dictates.
Thus as the system slides into crisis, it will take us with it. When
capitalism falls, it will fall on you, unless we discover possible
alternatives to the way human life is currently organized.
A BEGINNING: TRANSCENDENCE
We envision the supersession of the
economy, politics, the State, as the real means of pulling ourselves
beyond the world crisis. If that sounds impossible, we say that the
trajectory humanity finds itself on right now will produce the
impossibility of living on this planet, in any way that sustains
civilization, or even sustains the human species. What is required of
us is a class-conscious movement that aims for collective
self-management, beyond the current set-up (a set-up which requires alienation and
separate power, and stands in opposition to human needs and desire).
Such a movement requires an awakened humanity, ready to engage in a
world-historical act of self-transformation, and to create the means to
self-manage social life. Radical direct democracy would be both the
means and the goal.. We are not advocating a utopia, an ideal state, or
panacea. We do not advocate party control, hierarchies, politics as
usual, legislative
alternatives. We are not advocating the violent overthrow of any state.
But what we seek is the supersession of our current economic and
political forms. What we seek is an ongoing experiment in direct
democracy which would evolve according to historical possibilities.
Power without mediators, power
exercised by the "base" of society, not disowned or projected or
alienated into a class above ourselves — direct democracy through
collective forms of self-management... to be continued.
For those who wish to explore these ideas, see our list, "Suggested Online Readings".
— communications —
https://committee-for-transcendence.org
kathykundalini@committee-for-transcendence.org
— collaborations —
https://point-of-departure.org
rasputin@point-of-departure.org